WWE Extreme Rules 2009: Full Show Review

What's up, wrestling fans! Get ready to dive back into a night of pure chaos and unforgettable moments because we're talking about WWE Extreme Rules 2009! This event, which originally aired on June 7, 2009, was a game-changer, living up to its name with some absolutely brutal and innovative matches. It was the debut of the Extreme Rules concept, and boy, did they deliver. From ladder matches to steel cage showdowns, this pay-per-view was packed with action that left us all on the edge of our seats. So, grab your favorite snacks, settle in, and let's break down one of the most talked-about WWE events of the late 2000s. This was a night where rules were not just bent, they were completely shattered, setting a new standard for what extreme could truly mean in professional wrestling. The anticipation leading up to this event was palpable, with WWE hyping up the 'no holds barred' nature of the contests. We saw champions tested, careers on the line, and grudges settled in the most violent ways possible. It was a showcase of the roster's grit and determination, proving that they could push the boundaries of what was expected in a wrestling match. The sheer unpredictability of the outcomes added to the excitement, making every match feel like it had genuine stakes. This event wasn't just about winning; it was about surviving and proving who the toughest competitor was. The atmosphere was electric, fueled by the raucous crowd that was eager to witness history being made. Each match built upon the last, escalating the intensity and the stakes. It was a masterclass in storytelling through physical combat, with every blow and every near-fall designed to elicit a visceral reaction from the audience. The creative team behind this event deserves a huge shout-out for conceptualizing a show that truly embodied the 'Extreme Rules' moniker. They managed to balance the spectacle with the substance, ensuring that the matches weren't just hardcore for the sake of it, but rather integral to the ongoing narratives of the superstars involved. This was a pivotal moment for many wrestlers, who used this platform to establish themselves as main-event talent capable of handling the most demanding and dangerous stipulations. The legacy of Extreme Rules 2009 is undeniable, and revisiting it today is a treat for any fan who appreciates the more unadulterated and aggressive side of professional wrestling.

Undisputed WWE Champion: CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy

Alright guys, let's kick things off with a match that was brewing with intensity: CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy for the World Heavyweight Championship. Now, this rivalry was personal, and you could feel it in every single second of this ladder match. Punk, the opportunistic heel, had cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase on Hardy just a few months prior, stealing the title. Hardy, fueled by a desire for revenge and the championship gold, was out for blood. This wasn't just any ladder match; it was a Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match, which meant even more ways to inflict pain and claim victory. The stakes were incredibly high, and the narrative was simple yet effective: Hardy wanted to reclaim what was his, and Punk wanted to prove he was the best by retaining his title against the odds. The crowd was absolutely electric, completely invested in Hardy's quest for redemption. Every time Hardy got close to the title, the arena erupted. Conversely, Punk's heelish tactics and his increasingly dominant reign made him a perfect foil for the beloved underdog. The chemistry between these two was off the charts, and they didn't hold back. We saw sick bumps, brutal chair shots, and daring ladder spots that really defined the 'extreme' aspect of the show. Punk's agility and strategic mind combined with Hardy's high-risk, high-flying style made for a classic encounter. The psychology of the match was fantastic, with both men targeting each other's weaknesses and exploiting every opportunity. Hardy's desperation was evident as he climbed, only to be thwarted by Punk's cunning. Punk, on the other hand, showcased his resilience and his ability to adapt, using the environment to his advantage. The finish was controversial and cemented Punk's status as a top-tier heel. He managed to retain the championship after a grueling battle, leaving Hardy devastated and the fans stunned. This match was a significant moment for CM Punk, solidifying his transition into a major player in WWE. It was a testament to his in-ring abilities and his charisma, proving he could carry a major feud and deliver a show-stealing performance. Jeff Hardy, as always, gave it his all, performing daredevil feats that fans would remember for years. The storytelling in this match was top-notch, making it a must-watch for anyone who appreciates intense, character-driven wrestling. The sheer physicality and the emotional stakes made this ladder match one of the most memorable of the era, and a fitting opener for a show that promised chaos.

Undisputed WWE Champion: CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy - TLC Match Analysis

Delving deeper into the CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy TLC match for the World Heavyweight Championship, we witnessed a masterclass in storytelling and high-risk wrestling. CM Punk, the reigning champion, was riding a wave of momentum, having successfully defended his title in various grueling encounters. His opponent, Jeff Hardy, was the epitome of a fan favorite, a daredevil whose acrobatic style and emotional connection with the WWE Universe made him a constant threat. The narrative leading into this bout was intensely personal. Punk had defeated Hardy in a ladder match to win the championship, a victory that Hardy felt was stolen. This fueled Hardy's burning desire for retribution and a chance to reclaim the title he felt was rightfully his. The Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match stipulation itself added an extra layer of brutality, ensuring that this would be far from a conventional wrestling match. The environment was designed for destruction, and both competitors embraced it wholeheartedly. From the opening bell, the pace was frenetic. Both men understood the stakes and the need to deliver an unforgettable performance. We saw an early exchange of stiff chair shots, establishing the unforgiving nature of the contest. Jeff Hardy, in true 'Charismatic Enigma' fashion, was the first to ascend a ladder, attempting to retrieve the championship belts hanging above. However, CM Punk, ever the strategist, used the ring ropes and the surrounding equipment to his advantage, preventing Hardy from securing the win. The match was a seesaw battle, with momentum shifting multiple times. Both Superstars utilized the weapons at their disposal with vicious intent. Ladders were used not just for climbing but as battering rams, and tables were strategically placed for devastating impact. One particularly memorable spot involved Hardy performing a breathtaking Swanton Bomb off a ladder onto Punk, who was laid out on a table. The crowd's reaction to this was deafening, a testament to Hardy's willingness to put his body on the line for the entertainment of the fans. CM Punk showed incredible resilience, absorbing Hardy's offense and fighting back with calculated strikes and submission attempts. His ability to weather the storm and maintain focus, even amidst the chaos, highlighted his growing prowess as a top-tier performer. The match reached its climax with both men making desperate climbs up the ladder. In a controversial turn of events, CM Punk managed to pull down the championship belts while simultaneously executing a GTS on Jeff Hardy, securing his victory and retaining the World Heavyweight Championship. This finish was pivotal for Punk's character, solidifying his reign as a cunning and dominant champion who wasn't afraid to bend the rules to his advantage. For Jeff Hardy, it was another heartbreaking loss, but his performance cemented his legacy as one of the most exciting and courageous competitors in WWE history. The TLC match between CM Punk and Jeff Hardy at Extreme Rules 2009 was more than just a wrestling match; it was a brutal, emotional, and unforgettable spectacle that perfectly embodied the spirit of the event. It set a high bar for future TLC matches and remains a fan-favorite for its intensity and storytelling.

The Showstopper: John Cena vs. The Big Show

Next up on our journey through Extreme Rules 2009, we have a clash of titans: John Cena vs. The Big Show. This was a No Disqualification match, and let me tell you, it was exactly what you'd expect from these two behemoths. The story here was about power, dominance, and a rivalry that had been simmering. Cena, the perennial fan favorite and former WWE Champion, found himself in a fierce battle against the colossal Big Show, who was portrayed as an unstoppable force. The 'No DQ' stipulation meant that anything and everything was legal, from steel chairs to the ring bell, and these two certainly didn't disappoint in utilizing the environment. The match was a brutal display of strength, with both men exchanging powerful blows. You could see the impact of every slam and every clothesline. The Big Show, in particular, looked like a monster, using his size and strength to his advantage. He dominated large portions of the match, tossing Cena around like a rag doll and making the audience fear for the "Champ's" safety. Cena, however, is known for his resilience and his "never give up" attitude. He absorbed an incredible amount of punishment, fighting back with his signature intensity. The crowd was firmly behind Cena, chanting his name and urging him on. The drama unfolded with Cena making a valiant comeback, hitting his signature moves and trying to overcome the massive obstacle that was Big Show. There were moments where it looked like Big Show had Cena beat, but Cena always managed to find a way to kick out or reverse the momentum. The match wasn't just about raw power; it also featured some clever use of the no-disqualification rules. Chairs came into play, and the ring area became a battlefield. Cena even managed to use the steel steps to his advantage, delivering a powerful FU (now known as the Attitude Adjustment) onto Big Show. The visual of Cena lifting and slamming such a massive opponent was always a crowd-pleaser. The finish was a testament to Cena's fighting spirit. After a grueling back-and-forth, Cena managed to secure the victory, albeit through some questionable means, which added to the heelish persona Big Show was starting to develop. The match was a perfect example of Cena's ability to connect with the audience and overcome seemingly insurmountable odds. It showcased the power and destructive capabilities of The Big Show, making him a credible threat. This bout was a physical war, and while it might not have been the most technically intricate match on the card, it delivered on the promise of a hard-hitting, no-holds-barred contest that was fitting for the Extreme Rules brand. It was a classic big-man brawl that left a lasting impression on the fans.

John Cena vs. The Big Show - No Disqualification Carnage

Let's break down the No Disqualification match between John Cena and The Big Show at Extreme Rules 2009 because, guys, this was pure, unadulterated brawling. John Cena, the face of the company, was up against the towering Big Show, a man who could literally throw competitors around the ring like toys. The 'No Disqualification' stipulation meant that the usual rules were thrown out the window, and the entire arena was fair game for weapons and destruction. This set the stage for a contest that was less about technical wrestling and more about raw power and brute force. From the outset, it was clear that this match would be a test of endurance and toughness. The Big Show immediately asserted his dominance, using his immense size and strength to overpower Cena. He delivered thunderous clotheslines, devastating slams, and generally made Cena look like he was in serious trouble. The crowd was absolutely captivated, sensing that Cena was in uncharted territory against such a formidable opponent. There were multiple instances where it seemed like the match was over, with Big Show landing his signature "chokeslam" or "W.M.D.," only for Cena to somehow find the strength to kick out. This is where Cena's legendary resilience truly shone through. He absorbed an incredible amount of punishment, demonstrating his trademark "never give up" attitude. The audience was on their feet, chanting "Cena! Cena!" providing him with the energy to fight back. As the match progressed, the "no disqualification" aspect truly came into play. Steel chairs became weapons of choice, and both men used them with brutal effectiveness. The ring apron and the ringside area turned into a battleground. John Cena, showing his resourcefulness, managed to utilize the steel steps, even hitting a powerful "Attitude Adjustment" (then known as the FU) onto Big Show, driving him onto the steps. This was a pivotal moment that shifted the momentum back in Cena's favor. The finish itself was a bit of a nail-biter. After a prolonged and punishing exchange, John Cena ultimately secured the victory. While the specifics of the finish might be debated, the overall narrative was clear: Cena, against all odds, managed to overcome the destructive force of The Big Show. This match was a classic example of a "big man" brawl, perfectly suited for the Extreme Rules theme. It showcased the immense power of The Big Show while highlighting John Cena's incredible heart and ability to fight through adversity. It was a visceral and impactful encounter that left the WWE Universe buzzing.

The Women's Division Steals the Show: Michelle McCool vs. Beth Phoenix

Now, let's shift gears to the women's division, because Michelle McCool vs. Beth Phoenix for the Divas Championship was an absolute banger! This match, a "I Quit" match, was incredibly personal and delivered some serious intensity. These two ladies proved that the women could go just as hard, if not harder, than the men when given the opportunity. Michelle McCool, as the arrogant heel champion, was looking to cement her dominance, while Beth Phoenix, the powerful "Glamazon," was seeking to reclaim the title and prove her superiority. The "I Quit" stipulation is always a crowd-pleaser because it guarantees that the match won't end via pinfall or submission in the traditional sense; someone has to verbally give up, which often leads to brutal, drawn-out battles. And these two certainly delivered on that promise. The match was a showcase of technical prowess and sheer grit. Both women utilized submissions, strikes, and the environment to try and force the other to quit. Beth Phoenix used her strength to her advantage, tossing McCool around and applying punishing holds. McCool, on the other hand, used her speed and cunning, often employing dirty tactics to gain the upper hand. What made this match so compelling was the personal animosity between the two. It wasn't just about a championship; it was about pride and respect. They targeted each other's weaknesses, and the intensity never wavered. We saw brutal submission holds, chair shots, and near-quits that had the audience on the edge of their seats. The psychology of the match was fantastic, with each woman refusing to back down, leading to prolonged struggles and dramatic reversals. The crowd was heavily invested, appreciating the effort and the intensity displayed by both competitors. The finish came when McCool, in a moment of desperation and showing her heelish character, used Beth Phoenix's signature move, the "Glam Slam," on Beth Phoenix, and then locked in her own submission hold, forcing Phoenix to utter the dreaded words, "I Quit." It was a surprising and somewhat controversial finish, but it perfectly encapsulated McCool's character as a champion who would do anything to win. This match was a significant moment for the Divas division, proving that women's wrestling could be just as captivating and hard-hitting as the men's matches. It was a testament to the talent of both McCool and Phoenix, who delivered a memorable and brutal encounter that lived up to the "Extreme Rules" name. It stands as one of the standout matches from this historic event.

Michelle McCool vs. Beth Phoenix - "I Quit" Match Deep Dive

Let's get into the nitty-gritty of the "I Quit" match between Michelle McCool and Beth Phoenix for the Divas Championship at Extreme Rules 2009. This wasn't just a Divas match; it was a grudge match with an "I Quit" stipulation, meaning the contest could only end when one competitor verbally surrendered. This stipulation inherently lends itself to brutality, and these two women delivered. Michelle McCool, the reigning Divas Champion, was the embodiment of a cocky, arrogant heel. Her reign was marked by a sense of entitlement, and she often relied on underhanded tactics to retain her championship. Her opponent, Beth Phoenix, the "Glamazon," was a powerhouse, known for her strength and athleticism. Phoenix had a legitimate grievance against McCool, and this "I Quit" match was her opportunity for retribution and to reclaim the Divas Championship. The match kicked off with a palpable sense of intensity. Both competitors were clearly determined to inflict pain and force the other to submit. Beth Phoenix immediately showcased her superior strength, dominating McCool with powerful slams and submission holds. She was relentless in her pursuit of McCool's surrender, applying pressure that would make any opponent buckle. However, Michelle McCool proved to be a cunning and resilient opponent. She absorbed Phoenix's punishment and strategically used the environment and any available weapons to her advantage. She wasn't afraid to employ dirty tactics, which is characteristic of her heel persona. The "I Quit" stipulation led to some truly grueling exchanges. We saw submission holds applied with agonizing intensity, with both women pushing each other to their absolute limits. The crowd was fully engaged, sensing the genuine animosity and the physical toll the match was taking on both competitors. There were moments where one woman seemed on the verge of quitting, only for the other to find a renewed surge of energy or a clever reversal. The narrative was compelling: the dominant powerhouse versus the cunning strategist, with the "I Quit" stipulation ensuring a dramatic conclusion. The finish was quite controversial and spoke volumes about McCool's character. After a lengthy and punishing battle, Michelle McCool resorted to a devious tactic. She utilized Beth Phoenix's own finishing move, the "Glam Slam," against her, and then locked in a painful submission hold. Faced with no other option and immense pain, Beth Phoenix was forced to utter the words "I Quit," relinquishing the Divas Championship to McCool. This finish was a bold statement from McCool, solidifying her reputation as a ruthless champion who would do whatever it takes to win. The match was a significant highlight for the Divas division, demonstrating that the women could produce compelling, hard-hitting contests that were just as exciting as the men's matches. It was a testament to the talent and dedication of both McCool and Phoenix, delivering a brutal and memorable "I Quit" encounter that perfectly fit the Extreme Rules theme.

Other Notable Matches and Moments

Beyond the main events, Extreme Rules 2009 was packed with other exciting matches and memorable moments that contributed to its legacy. The Intercontinental Championship match between Rey Mysterio and Chris Jericho was a technical masterpiece. Jericho, playing the cowardly heel, was obsessed with Mysterio's mask, which held immense symbolic value. This match saw Jericho unmask Rey Mysterio, a moment that shocked the WWE Universe and led to Jericho winning the Intercontinental Championship. It was a significant storyline development that added a layer of controversy and drama to the night. Mysterio's masked persona is iconic, and seeing it ripped away by Jericho was a brutal display of Jericho's villainy. The match itself was a clinic in high-paced, skilled wrestling, with both men showcasing their incredible athleticism and ring IQ. Another noteworthy bout was the ECW Championship match featuring Christian defending his title against Tommy Dreamer. This was a "Extreme Rules" match, naturally, and it was a fitting tribute to the ECW legacy. Both men put on a gritty, hard-fought contest that showcased the ECW spirit of no-holds-barred action. Christian retained his title, but the match was celebrated for its intensity and its nod to ECW's hardcore roots. It was a battle that had a lot of heart, with Dreamer giving it his all for the championship he had chased for so long. The Six-Diva Tag Team Match, featuring Mickie James, Kelly Kelly, and CM Punk's former girlfriend, Maria Kanellis, against Maryse, Jillian Hall, and Alicia Fox, was also a solid addition to the card. While perhaps not as intense as the other matches, it provided a good showcase for the women on the roster and offered some entertaining action. These additional matches, while perhaps not the headliners, added depth and variety to the Extreme Rules 2009 card. They demonstrated the breadth of talent in WWE at the time and ensured that there was something for every type of wrestling fan. The unmasking of Rey Mysterio, in particular, became a talking point for weeks, highlighting the power of storytelling in professional wrestling. These moments, big and small, cemented Extreme Rules 2009 as a truly unforgettable night in WWE history, a night where the rules were indeed meant to be broken.

Conclusion: A Night of True Extremes

So there you have it, guys! WWE Extreme Rules 2009 was an absolute home run. It delivered on its promise of an "extreme" experience, pushing the boundaries with innovative match stipulations and delivering high-impact, emotionally charged contests. From the brutal TLC match between CM Punk and Jeff Hardy to the hard-hitting "I Quit" match involving Michelle McCool and Beth Phoenix, this pay-per-view was packed with moments that are still talked about today. The debut of the "Extreme Rules" branding was a massive success, setting a new standard for the type of action-packed, no-holds-barred wrestling that fans could expect. It wasn't just about the championships; it was about the raw intensity, the personal rivalries, and the sheer willingness of the superstars to put their bodies on the line. John Cena's victory over The Big Show in a No DQ match, Chris Jericho unmasking Rey Mysterio, and Christian retaining the ECW Championship in a fitting "Extreme Rules" match all added to the incredible tapestry of this event. This pay-per-view truly showcased the versatility and the dedication of the WWE roster. Each match, regardless of its position on the card, contributed to the overall theme of pushing limits and embracing chaos. Extreme Rules 2009 wasn't just another wrestling show; it was an event. It proved that when given the freedom to break free from conventional rules, the talent in WWE could produce some truly unforgettable and groundbreaking television. If you're looking for a night of pure wrestling adrenaline, brutal action, and compelling storylines, then WWE Extreme Rules 2009 is a must-watch. It remains a benchmark for hardcore wrestling and a testament to the power of "extreme" in professional wrestling. It’s a show that reminds us why we fell in love with this crazy business in the first place – the drama, the athleticism, and the sheer spectacle of it all. This event solidified its place in WWE history as a night where the rules were truly optional, and the action was anything but. It was a night that fans remember fondly, a testament to the booking, the performances, and the overall spirit of the event. It perfectly captured the essence of what a "rules-optional" wrestling show should be, leaving a lasting impression on the WWE Universe.